Get Your Free Cash Offer Now!
Fill out this form to get your no-obligation all cash offer started!
Get Your Free Offer TODAY!
Fill In This Form To Get Your No-Obligation All Cash Offer Started!
Landlords Sell Rentals All the Time in Indianapolis. Here’s Why
Owning rental property isn’t always passive income. Between repairs, maintenance calls, and lease management, it becomes a full-time job. That’s why many Indianapolis landlords sell their rentals each year. Some want to retire from real estate. Others are tired of chasing late rent or dealing with property damage. In some cases, they may also be trying to sell a house in Indianapolis even if they’re behind on payments which can make things even more stressful.
No matter your reason, you don’t have to wait until your lease is up. You can sell your property as-is, with tenants still living in it.
Can You Sell a House With Tenants in Indianapolis?
Yes. Indiana law allows you to sell a rental property while it’s tenant-occupied. You just need to follow a few legal requirements:
- Honor the current lease agreement
- Provide proper notice before showings or inspections
- Respect tenant privacy and access laws
If your tenants are on a month-to-month lease, you can give notice to vacate (usually 30 days) before closing, or sell the property with the tenants in place. If they have a fixed-term lease, they are entitled to stay through the end of the lease unless they agree to move early.
Tons of Amazing Reviews from Homeowners in Indiana
We've bought countless houses in Indiana fast and without stress. Here's what a few of them had to say:
Hal Jones
"Knowledgeable, Professional, and Trustworthy!"
"Loyal Home Buyers are a knowledgeable and professional group of folks. You will surely be glad you chose these gents to solve any issue you have. I will definitely be speaking with Jonathan or Kyle if I need to sell a home in their area."
Castilia Cava
"Transparent and Smooth Process!"
"Selling our house with Loyal Home Buyers was a really good experience. What I appreciated most was how transparent they were. Jonathan walked us through the whole process and explained exactly how they came up with their offer.
At first, we were hoping for a little more, but after seeing the breakdown of costs and repairs, it totally made sense. They were honest, professional, and kept us updated the whole time.
We closed in about 3 weeks with no issues. I would definitely recommend them if you want a smooth, straightforward sale."
Your Options: Sell With or Without the Tenants
You have two options when selling a rental:
1. Sell With Tenants In Place
This is often the fastest way to close. You can sell directly to a real estate investor who buys rental properties and is comfortable inheriting tenants. There’s no need to schedule showings, clean up the home, or relocate your tenants. Investors buy the house as-is, handle the lease, and manage the transition.
This works best when:
- You have reliable, paying tenants
- The lease has several months left
- You don’t want to disrupt your cash flow before the sale
2. Sell After Asking Tenants to Vacate
If your lease allows it or tenants are on a month-to-month agreement, you can provide notice and sell the home vacant. This route is more common when:
- The tenants are behind on rent
- The home needs repairs or cleaning
- You want to sell to a homeowner instead of another landlord
Vacant properties allow you to clean, repair, or stage the home for higher offers. But if time is more important than top dollar, a direct sale to a cash buyer is faster and simpler.
Avoiding the Common Headaches
Many Indianapolis landlords delay selling because they worry about tenant conflict or legal hurdles. Here’s the good news. You can avoid most of those issues when you work with a local investor.
Cash buyers like Loyal Home Buyers specialize in buying rental properties fast. We’ve purchased dozens of homes in Indianapolis with tenants still living inside. Here’s how we handle it:
- We contact the tenant directly (if allowed) to explain the transition
- We honor the current lease or work out a solution that respects all parties
- We buy the house as-is. No repairs, no cleaning
You avoid listing on the MLS, paying agent fees, or coordinating showings. Best of all, you close on your timeline. If you’re deciding between a traditional agent or a direct sale, it’s worth knowing the differences. Here’s how to evaluate a cash buyer vs. realtor when you need to sell fast in Indianapolis.
What to Tell Your Tenants When You Sell
It’s smart to keep communication clear. You’re legally required to notify your tenants of the sale, especially if their lease will remain in place. You can let them know:
- The property is being sold
- Their lease will be honored (if applicable)
- They do not have to move immediately unless notified in writing
- The new owner will provide further communication
Avoid creating panic. When tenants understand their rights and what to expect, the process usually runs smoothly.
Selling to an Investor vs. Listing With an Agent
Listing With an Agent
If you list with an agent, you may need to:
- Wait until the lease ends
- Ask tenants to keep the home clean for showings
- Make repairs to appeal to buyers
- Pay commissions and closing costs
This process can take 60 to 90 days or more, and traditional agent commissions can significantly reduce your profit.
Selling to a Cash Buyer
Selling to Loyal Home Buyers is quicker. We provide a fair all-cash offer in 24 hours and can close in as little as 7 days. You skip the hassles of showings, repairs, and delays. Plus, we work with you to keep things respectful and legal for your tenants. This kind of flexibility is especially helpful if you're also navigating other major life changes, like selling a house during divorce in Indianapolis.
What Happens at Closing?
When you sell your rental to a cash buyer:
- You get a fair all-cash offer (usually within 24 hours)
- No appraisals, inspections, or financing delays
- You choose your closing date
- We cover typical closing costs
- You hand over keys and collect your funds
You walk away with cash, even if your tenants are still living in the property. If the home needs work, it’s smart to be aware of possible code violations that could slow things down.
You Don’t Have to Wait
You don’t have to wait for lease terms, repairs, or listing prep. You don’t need to pay an agent or worry about open houses.
Whether your tenants are great or giving you grief, we’re ready to make you an offer.
Want a stress-free sale? Learn more about our home-buying process. It’s built for landlords like you.
Get Your Free Cash Offer Now!
Fill out this form to get your no-obligation all cash offer started!
Get Your Free Offer TODAY!
Fill In This Form To Get Your No-Obligation All Cash Offer Started!
Ready to Sell Your Rental Property in Indianapolis?
Sell your house fast in Indianapolis. Fill out the form below. We’ll provide a fair all-cash offer and handle everything, with or without your tenants in place.
You don’t need to clean, repair, or stage anything. We make it simple to sell a tenant-occupied property without disrupting your income or your renters. From the first call to closing, we keep things straightforward so you can move forward with confidence.